The Credit Was for People Who Couldn’t Work. She Added It for $800 a Return.

On October 16, 2026, a federal judge in Indiana sentenced an Evansville tax return preparer to a year and a day in prison for putting false pandemic-era credits on her clients’ tax returns. The government put the tax loss at roughly $965,000 across about 123 returns.

That is the news. The quieter question underneath it: when a preparer builds a refund out of entries that were never true, what happens to the taxpayer whose name is on the return?

What the court record says

According to the announcement from IRS Criminal Investigation and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Indiana, Tonda Avery operated Diversity Tax Service in Evansville. She prepared federal income tax returns for clients and employed other preparers at the firm.

Avery pleaded guilty to five counts of aiding and assisting in the preparation and presentation of a false and fraudulent tax return. U.S. District Judge Matthew P. Brookman sentenced her to one year and one day in federal prison, followed by one year of supervised release, and ordered her to pay $1,318,455.43 in restitution. The case was investigated by IRS Criminal Investigation.

How the scheme worked

The vehicle was Form 7202. During the pandemic, that form let eligible self-employed people claim refundable credits for periods when they could not work for reasons related to COVID-19. It was a real benefit aimed at real people — a sole proprietor who was sick, quarantined or caring for a child whose school had closed.

Two things made it attractive to someone inventing numbers. The credits were refundable, so they could generate a refund larger than the tax owed. And the facts behind them lived in the taxpayer’s own recollection, not on a form a third party mails to the IRS.

For clients who had no business at all

Form 7202 only works if there is self-employment income behind it. So, according to the government, Avery created fictitious businesses and prepared false Schedule C forms reporting business income and expenses that did not exist. Those invented Schedules C then supported Forms 7202 claiming sick and family leave credits the clients were not entitled to.

The fake business was not the goal. It was scaffolding, built so a credit could be hung off it.

For clients who did have a business

Where a client genuinely was self-employed, the government says Avery inflated the inputs instead — the days the client supposedly could not work, and the net earnings used to size the credit. Nothing looked invented. The numbers were simply bigger than the truth.

The $800 upcharge

When Avery added a fraudulent Schedule C and Form 7202 to a client’s return, she increased her fee by $800. The government also says she instructed and encouraged other preparers at her firm to prepare fraudulent returns, including returns containing false Forms 7202.

“Tax preparers are paid to know the rules—not rig them,” said Robert J. Kuszynski of IRS Criminal Investigation’s Chicago Field Office.

The number that made it visible

The announcement includes a comparison worth keeping in mind — the kind of thing the IRS can see and a single client cannot.

  • In 2020, about 33.82% of the returns Avery prepared included a Form 7202. Nationwide, about 0.90% of returns did. In Indiana, about 0.50%.
  • In 2021, about 61.14% of her returns included one. Nationwide, still about 0.90%. In Indiana, about 0.40%.

By the second year, three in five returns leaving that office claimed a credit that fewer than one in a hundred returns claimed anywhere else. No single client could have known that. The IRS, looking at a preparer’s whole book of business, could.

What this means for the people whose returns were involved

The announcement says nothing about what any individual client knew, and nothing about what has happened to them since. We are not going to fill that silence with guesses. What we can describe is how this situation generally works, because that is the part clients call us about.

A refundable credit claimed without entitlement can be disallowed and the tax reassessed, whether or not the taxpayer understood what was on the return. A preparer’s prosecution does not undo the filings. The criminal case against the preparer and any civil examination of a client are separate matters on separate tracks.

In practice that can look like:

  • A notice or examination letter arriving long after the refund was received and spent.
  • Repayment of a disallowed credit, with interest running from the original due date of the return.
  • Accuracy-related penalties, which can sometimes be contested where a taxpayer reasonably relied on a professional, but which are not removed automatically.
  • More than one year opening at once, since a preparer who filed this way in 2020 often filed the same way in 2021.
  • A fabricated Schedule C that has to be unwound as well, since the invented business affects self-employment tax and other items on the return.

None of that is automatic, and outcomes turn on the facts of the particular year and return. Reliance on a tax professional is a recognized argument against accuracy-related penalties. Records can support or defeat individual line items. An examination is a process with rules, deadlines and appeal rights. But it is a process that begins with a letter addressed to the taxpayer, not to the preparer.

If the IRS is questioning a credit someone else put on your return, you do not have to answer the examination alone — see how IRS audit representation works.

The warning signs a taxpayer could have spotted

Most CPAs, enrolled agents and seasonal preparers do careful work under real deadline pressure, and cases like this one irritate them more than anyone. The point of listing warning signs is not that the profession is suspect. It is that the few bad actors tend to leave the same marks, and a client who knows where to look can see them.

  • A Schedule C for a business you do not have. Page one of your 1040 should not report self-employment income if you were a W-2 employee all year. This is the single clearest tell in the Avery case.
  • A credit you cannot explain in a sentence. If you cannot say which days you were unable to work and why, a Form 7202 does not belong on your return.
  • A refund much larger than last year with no change in your life to match it. Ask which line changed. A good preparer can point to it.
  • An add-on fee for a specific credit. A flat charge that appears only when a particular form is attached is a fee tied to the form, not to the work.
  • No preparer signature and no PTIN. Paid preparers are required to sign and include their Preparer Tax Identification Number. A blank preparer section leaves you holding the return by yourself.
  • Not being shown the full return before it is filed. You are entitled to review every page, including the schedules.

What to do if you think this happened to you

  1. Pull your own transcripts. Get your account and wage and income transcripts from your IRS online account, so you are looking at what the IRS has rather than the copy your preparer handed you.
  2. Look for a Schedule C and a Form 7202 on your 2020 and 2021 returns. If either is there and you cannot account for it, note it and keep going.
  3. Write down what was actually true for each year. Your real income, your real work status, your real days unable to work.
  4. Keep what you gave your preparer. Engagement letters, texts, the documents you handed over and the fees you paid all matter if reasonable reliance becomes part of your position.
  5. Do not ignore a notice. Examination letters carry deadlines, and your options narrow as those deadlines pass.
  6. Get represented before you start explaining. An examination is not a conversation where volunteering more is automatically rewarded. A representative can deal with the IRS on your behalf and keep the scope where it belongs.

Avery’s sentence is set. Her former clients are on a different clock. For them the question was never how many months she would get. It is what the IRS does with the returns still filed under their names, and whether anyone is standing with them if a letter about one of those years arrives.


Discover more from IRS Trouble Solvers

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.